Heat pump, solar timer or solar hot water? How to heat water with your solar, when economy tariffs still make sense, and what to plan before the old tank dies.

It always happens on a cold morning. You turn on the shower, wait, wait a bit longer, and realise the water is not getting any warmer. The old hot water system has finally given up, and now you have about a day to make a decision that will shape your power bill for the next decade.
If you have solar on the roof, that decision has become a lot more interesting. Hot water is one of the biggest energy users in a Brisbane home, and the way you heat it can either soak up your cheap daytime solar or quietly add to your bill every night.
Below we compare the three main electric options for solar homes: an ordinary electric tank running on a solar timer, a heat pump, and solar hot water. We also cover the Energex economy tariffs, the incentives available at the time of writing, and what to think about before the old tank dies.
According to the Australian Government's Energy Rating program, about 25% of the average Australian household energy bill is associated with water heating. A UNSW research team puts the range at roughly 15 to 30% of household energy use, second only to heating and cooling.
It is also one of the few big loads you can genuinely shift. You cannot move your fridge to the middle of the day, but you can heat a tank of water at noon and use it at 7pm. An electric tank works a bit like a battery that stores heat.
The same UNSW research notes that more than half of Australian households use electric storage water heaters, and that many of them were set up to heat overnight on off-peak tariffs. That made sense before rooftop solar. For a lot of solar homes today, it is the wrong way round.

This is the simplest upgrade, and often the cheapest. If your electric tank is in good condition, it may just need to heat at a different time.
Many older Brisbane homes have the hot water wired to an Energex economy tariff, usually Tariff 31 or Tariff 33. These circuits are separately metered and switched by the network. Energex says Tariff 31 supplies power for 8 or more hours, typically around 10pm to 7am, while Tariff 33 supplies power for 18 or more hours a day, usually outside 4pm to 9pm.
The catch is that rooftop solar usually feeds your main household circuits, not the separately metered economy circuit. So if your tank is heating overnight on Tariff 31, it is not using your solar at all.
A licensed electrician can move the tank onto your main tariff and fit a timer so the element only runs during solar hours, often somewhere around late morning to mid-afternoon. Some households use a solar diverter instead, which sends surplus solar to the element as it becomes available. The UNSW researchers note that about a quarter of households have opted out of controlled load circuits so they can heat water from rooftop solar, though timers or diverters add some cost.
An element is still the least efficient way to heat water with electricity, and on cloudy days the tank may need a grid top-up. If you have little spare solar, Tariff 33 may still be cheaper. Decide with your bills in front of you.
Quick tip: Check your bill for a separate line labelled economy, controlled load or Tariff 31 or 33. That tells you your hot water (or pool pump) is on its own circuit, and it is the first thing an electrician will want to know.
A heat pump works like a reverse air conditioner. Instead of using an element to create heat, it uses a fan and compressor to pull heat from the surrounding air and move it into the water.
Efficiency is measured as the coefficient of performance (COP): how many units of heat you get for each unit of electricity used. An electric element has a COP of about 1. Manufacturer COP figures for heat pumps listed by CHOICE range from about 2.5 at 0 degrees to well above 5 in warm conditions, which is one reason they suit a climate like Brisbane's.
Solar Victoria, the Victorian Government's solar agency, says heat pumps use around 60 to 75% less electricity than a conventional electric hot water system. Pair that with a timer so the unit runs in the middle of the day, when the air is warmest and your panels are producing, and the running cost can drop a long way.
Heat pumps have a fan and a compressor, so they make some noise. Solar Victoria describes it as typically similar to a fridge. Ergon Energy says it can be about the level of a medium-sized air conditioner. Either way, placement matters:
Heat pumps cost more upfront than a basic tank and have more moving parts. Models listed by CHOICE ranged from about $2,360 to $7,910 before installation, so quality and price vary widely. Look at the warranty and local support, not just the price.
Solar thermal systems use collectors on the roof (flat panels or evacuated tubes) to heat water directly from the sun. A booster, usually electric, tops up the temperature when the sun is not enough.
Ergon Energy says that in Queensland, the sun can provide about 80% of the energy for a solar hot water system.

For many homes with solar panels, a heat pump or timed tank now makes better use of the roof. If your roof is large and your array small, solar hot water is still worth a look.
For homes without solar, or with only a small system, Tariff 31 and Tariff 33 can still make sense. Ergon Energy says connecting hot water to Tariff 33 can save up to about 19% on water heating costs compared with the standard tariff.
The ground is shifting, though. Energex notes that economy tariff supply schedules are moving towards the middle of the day to soak up rooftop solar, with supply typically interrupted during the morning peak and resumed around midday. If you have a timer on your system, it may need its settings updated as these schedules change.
A few rules to keep in mind:
If you want to understand where the rest of your bill goes, our guide to why Brisbane power bills keep climbing covers supply charges, time-of-use plans and the Solar Sharer Offer.
The main incentive for heat pumps and solar hot water is federal, through small-scale technology certificates (STCs) under the Small-scale Renewable Energy Scheme. Eligible systems are listed on the Clean Energy Regulator's register, and installers usually take the certificates as a discount on your price.
Two things to know for 2027:
On the state side, Queensland's earlier Climate Smart Energy Savers appliance rebate, which included heat pump and solar hot water systems, has not been active since 2023, and we are not aware of a current Queensland Government hot water rebate at the time of writing. Programs come and go, so check before you buy.
Quick tip: Be wary of hot water deals that sound too good to be true. Ask who is installing it, whether they hold the right plumbing licence endorsement, and who does the electrical connection.
Most people replace their hot water in a hurry, so a like-for-like tank goes back in and the chance to do something smarter disappears for another decade.
If your tank is getting on, or showing signs like rust, leaks around the base or lukewarm water, it pays to plan before it fails. Think about:
If a battery or an EV is on the cards, the order you do things in matters. Our whole-home energy solutions page explains how solar, batteries, hot water and EV charging can work together, and our solar installation page covers sizing your system for the loads you actually have.

Often, yes. If it is currently on an economy tariff, a licensed electrician can move it to your main circuit and fit a timer or diverter so it heats during solar hours. Whether it saves you money depends on your solar surplus and your tariff.
Brisbane's mild climate suits heat pumps, and they use far less electricity than an electric element. Whether the higher upfront cost pays off depends on your hot water use, your current system and your tariff.
The main support at the time of writing is federal STCs, which reduce the upfront price and step down each year to 2030. We are not aware of a current Queensland Government hot water rebate, but check before you buy.
Josh is a licensed electrician who designs and installs his systems himself, so you get straight advice from the person who will do the work. Send through your recent bills and a photo of your hot water system and meter box, and he can look at how your solar, tariff and hot water fit together, then tell you whether a timer, a different tariff or a new system is worth it. Book your free energy assessment today.
Related